Friday, 6 November 2026

Just him being him

 


I’ve never been sure about Russell Brand, even from his rise to fame when I used to watch Big Brother in the early 2000s. I found him brash, and, I suppose, slightly inappropriate. More recently, his social media presence that occasionally popped up in my reels during Covid, where he shared conspiracy theories and denied the pandemic, then his very public journey to faith, left for me questions hanging in the air about his genuineness in it all. I remember the picture of him with a group of “celebrity” Christians, whose names are up there in the Church world, and that picture of him baptising in his underwear, which was frankly, rather weird.

It’s just Russell Brand though, isn’t it?

That’s the problem.

Yesterday Brand was convicted of rape and sexual assault, and more alleged victims have come forward. He had a reputation for promiscuity when he was working in TV, but he claims that anything was consensual, pleading not guilty on all counts. His bad behaviour was normalised and dismissed by those around him and when women spoke up, little or no action was taken.

It’s just Russell Brand though, isn’t it? It’s what celebrity is like.

That’s the problem.

I’ve been following the Russell Brand story for some time, not least because of his story of his journey to faith. In the midst of the allegations brought against him, he has claimed a turnaround in his life as he met with Jesus. Honestly, I can’t tell whether his journey of faith is genuine or not, because I don’t trust him. He acts out the persona he wants to be. He lies. He has abused women.

The problem with men like Brand, is that they get into the positions they do because of personality and charisma. Brand is a marmite character, with many fans, and many, probably like me, who turn off the TV as soon as he arrives. I understand the attraction – he comes across as straight talking, genuine, funny, not afraid of what people think of him….. He’s not afraid to get his Bible out on TV and tries to quote Isaiah, and wears big crosses (but isn’t that just the showy faith the Biblical prophets, like Isaiah, speak out against?).

The problem with men like Brand, is that there are far too many like him. In Music, TV and film there is a stream of men being called out. In politics the men are held to lower account as past comments and actions that are just like Brands public persona, are subdued and hidden away because their policies appear to be good.

And in the church too, there’s a growing list of mostly men who have abused their positions of power for their own gratification. Brand, because of his position and his rise within the faith community, sits on both.

We need to speak out. We need to create cultures of goodness and wellbeing where all can thrive. While we let power hungry leaders and celebrities leave the dark side of their character locked in their bedrooms, and still give them platforms, we leave space for more people to be damaged by them.

We need to not ignore the signs, not avoid the difficult conversations, not leave those who have been abused scared to speak up because the power of the abuser silences their voices and has the potential to ruin their lives.

And we need to stop putting up with low level behaviour that makes women squirm, because so often it points to something worse. A prominent Methodist minister is currently on trial at Truro Crown Court where he faces 10 counts of sexual assault on a number of women and one indecent assault of a woman. This minister is described as one of those “handsy” men. He is overly tactile with women – and got away with it.

“It was just him being him”, those who took reports of his behaviour said.

When one woman spoke up she was told that the church was at war with Satan and to cause a fuss about that would undermine that war effort.

That’s a problem within some areas of the church. We think that calling out the behaviour of predators will somehow damage the spread of the Gospel.

But God is bigger than that. God’s salvation plan is overflowing with his goodness. How can we suppose that allowing this kind of behaviour can prevent his work? It, in fact, does just the opposite, and it turns people away from the God who loves them, who died for them, who emptied himself for them.

 The prophet Amos calls for a faith of integrity, where people seek God and his ways -  he says that “There are those who hate the one who upholds justice in court and detest the one who tells the truth” Amos 5:10

When we use celebrity status, outward appearance, or a claim that the gospel is being squashed because we’re calling out the abuse of power by those who lead us, then we need to come back to this. Our God is a good God. He transforms us, and restores us to a place of honour instead of shame. He doesn’t tell us to oppress the victim by leaving the perpetrator unpunished in the name of lifting up his name. In fact, Amos goes on to say,

“I hate, I despise your religious festivals; your assemblies are a stench to me…. Away with the noise of your songs! I will not listen to the music of your harps. But let justice roll like a river, righteousness like a never failing stream!” Amos 5:21-24

Let us be people who put justice for the victim over the comfort of the oppressor

Let us be people who call out where behaviour is wrong, not those who say “well it’s just them”

Let us be people who sit with those who are weeping, who stand with them when their life is falling apart.

Let us be people who speak goodness, and righteousness over people into our communities.

And let us never be people who abuse power and status and make others suffer for our own gain.

Let us be people who recognise when we have used power in the past to hurt others, and truly repent.

Let us be people who admit when we’ve got it wrong, and change our behaviour so that in the future we get it right.

Let us not be afraid to speak truth, and to act justly, love mercy and walk humbly with our God. 

Let us pray for those women who have stood up in court and told their story, for those who have been believed by the jury, and for those for whom justice has been denied.

Wednesday, 15 April 2026

Women, Ministry and Baptist Life. What next?



Since I wrote my blog on the more recent experiences of Baptist Ministry I've had a lot of feedback and encouragement. Women who have experienced the same have appreciated me putting it into words, those who have noticed the shift as they've watched the world change around them have expressed solidarity. Male colleagues in ministry have expressed sadness, anger and disappointment as well as deeply passionate and genuine support. One or two have asked what they can do to support me, and how to support women in general. 

It is the last I address now. This list is not definitive, and I am only one woman, with one woman's experience. I suggest that we all need to talk to and get to know the women ministers around us and hear what they say and experience - and then respond accordingly. 

Here is my personal list. 

Firstly keep your eyes and ears open to what is going on around you. If you haven't picked up on the trends that I've observed in my previous post, then test them, check them, see where they are true. You may be in rooms and at tables where it is normal to debate a theology that affects people calling and lives - how are you speaking into those spaces? If you were the woman in the room how would you feel? Someone said to me recently "I hear you are into women's ministry". I replied "well I am one". The people who are being talked about and whose ministry is being dismissed are often sitting there in the room. We might try hard to find balance in representation, but it isn't always reflected in how welcome is offered. 

Secondly, don't just get angry, call it out. I really appreciate the solidarity that so many of my male colleagues in ministry show by the way they stand by my side and seek to understand how this makes me feel. They affirm me, celebrate me and appreciate me. Carry on doing that - it does help.... but it could be taken one step further. If someone deliberately puts up barriers to women getting involved, ask why. If someone speaks out or preaches against women in ministry in a way that hurts their women colleagues unnecessarily, pick them up on it. They may not even know what they are doing. Call out unhelpful conversations in cluster meetings. Speak out your own views, drown out the rising voices. Walk away and refuse to participate - that's what some women are doing. 

Thirdly, check your own language and behaviour. You can say that you are supportive of women in ministry, but then, when the atmosphere is right, you get taken by the crowd. You can say you are supportive of women in ministry, but then you worry too much about what others may think. You can say you are supportive of women in ministry, but then you refer to all ministers as he or him or bros. You can say you are supportive of women in ministry, but always make sure your opinion is heard above theirs. Big up the work of Project Violet - don't play it down, depending on the room you are in. Live and speak like the Baptist Union has accepted and affirmed women in ministry for over 100 years. 

Fourthly, celebrate your female colleagues, make space for them in your pulpit (not just on Mothering Sunday or when you are on holiday), invite them to the tables where decisions are made, recognise them as equals, think carefully about whether its OK to take part in events where women may be invited but not fully allowed to participate (sometimes I think it is - if we're not in the room, how will things change?). Some of the hardest places for women who are gifted and called are those that allow women in, but only to a certain level, or only to speak if accompanied or "covered" by a husband or colleague. It's the reality of the space we live in. 

And finally in those places and conversations where women's ministry and gifts are not fully celebrated, encourage respect, consideration, helpful language and understanding. Ask the difficult questions that hang in the air.  

We are all human beings, made in the image of God, after all. 




Monday, 23 February 2026

Called, Tested, and Tired: Women, Ministry, and Baptist Life

 

On the way back from a Leeds University Christian Union Houseparty I had helped organise as treasurer, I was sat in the car with a former CU exec member as he drove along the M62 and he turned to me in the car and said, “Claire, you’re going to be a minister one day.” I’ve never forgotten that moment. When I tell the story of my call, I begin there. 

The call to ministry is a strange, all-encompassing journey of being convinced and giving in (that’s my experience anyway). It’s a call that you know will be sacrificial, change your life, and is only determined by God. The reason why we test a call to ministry so thoroughly is because it’s about who you are, not what you can do. It’s realising there is nothing else you should be doing but this. It’s knowing that God made you this way and by obeying his call you are completely submitting yourself to him.

As I grew up, I rarely met a woman minister, yet I was raised to believe I could become all God created me to be. I was a high achiever, always doing my best at school. I was a loner, not following the crowd, but trying to be my own person, perhaps at the back of my mind knowing that as someone made in the image of God, I needed to be no one but me. It has only been on my journey of call that I have discovered that there are people out there who think me being me is not who God has made me to be because they believe the Bible tells them so.


Being a woman in Baptist ministry brings with it a tension. A tension that I choose to live with because I love the Baptist family. This tension is created by our commitment to local church autonomy: some churches wholeheartedly affirm women’s leadership; there are a few who do not; and there are others in between. 

I am not going argue my position on women in ministry, because it is clear from my role that I believe it to be right and God ordained. I believe my call to be true. I believe that God spoke to me clearly in a tent when he gave me Isaiah 6 and told me I am one he wants to send. On my year out working with Christian Unions I studied fastidiously the texts that people continue to use to clobber me now and believed that I still needed to explore God’s call. I spent ten years exploring that – I did not come into this lightly. The Baptist Union has had a clear position as a body on women in ministry for a long time now, and I’ve written a resource, along with others, that helps churches explore that egalitarian theology, which is out there. I believe on that I have said enough, and I’m tired of arguing my very being with people (both men and women) who want to throw it back in my face. And there are other people who can do that better than I can. 

As a Regional Minister in London, I see both the beauty and the brokenness of Baptist life. I see unexpected growth, baptisms where the baptistry hasn't been opened in years, and churches persevering through hardship. I get to see and work with the amazing diversity of our churches, all trying to follow the way of Jesus as they seek to love and serve him in their communities.

But I also see the darker side: insecurity, control, and the quiet sidelining of certain voices. And over the past few years, I’ve seen that very acutely on the call of women into ministry. As I’ve talked about it with a number of colleagues – it sounds and feels like it's getting harder for women – and here I’d like to explore the reasons why:

Permission to Speak Out

I began this role in the midst of an incredible difficult season in our union - in the midst of the marriage consultation where existing divisions were highlighted. Debates about sexuality mixed with arguments about authority, and in that climate the question of women’s leadership became entangled in the conversation. Complementarian voices began to grow louder. 

The women in ministry argument became so entangled that when the results came out, and it was decided that the rules wouldn’t change, that it was noted that women were more likely to be voting for change, and therefore, in some commenters opinions, women were more likely to be theologically liberal. Assumptions were made online and left to fester and grow. (As an aside my personal take on this is that women are more used to living in tension, being that not all churches will accept them, and so living in tension amongst others whose theology of sexuality they might disagree with was an easier gap to leap). 

Public statements about male headship, in church and home, gained confidence, particularly as more prominent Baptist voices spoke out. What had once been spoken cautiously began to be said more openly, published online, discussed, not fully withdrawn, and instead pushed into the faces of women who are called to these roles. 

The need to be heard in the consultation debate, the assumptive interpretation of the results and the voices of some leaders within our union getting louder – it gave permission to speak out.

I remember my first ever ministers conference, where I was given the task of finding male advocates for women in ministry. I had a list of men who I needed to speak to, and I approached one, locally recognised minister, who took great pleasure in telling me, a woman minister in training, that my call to ministry was against creations order.

I thought that was a one off – but it’s not. Most recently, an experienced woman minister told me how she got caught up in a conversation about women in ministry with her male colleagues, which ended for her when one of those men told her she shouldn’t even be a minister. This confirmed to me what I had been feeling - that this was becoming more, not less, commonplace. 

The Backlash to Project Violet

Project Violet confirmed what many women already knew – that despite significant progress, structural and cultural barriers remain. While many welcomed its recommendations, others reacted defensively, suggesting that encouraging women disadvantages men or that the church has become “too feminised.” 

Project Violet has handed women a voice that has been muffled for some time and there are those who don’t like this and they talk back. Subtle, seemingly reasonable questions, often with a misogynistic twinge.

This backlash to women speaking out is not new or confined to the church, but we need to be aware of the effect it is having. There are some people who will not engage with the research, who will stay away from events, because they already fear what it means for them and believe it closes opportunities that were open before. 

Yet the Project has never been simply about privileging women; it is about the flourishing of the whole church—creating space for all whom God calls, especially those historically marginalised.

There is a rise in Non-Accredited ministers

There is a crisis of ministry in the Baptist Union - people are not coming forward for training. Why is this? There are probably a number of reasons that I won't go into here... but it's led to a change in our churches. 

That broader ministry shortage has led churches to look beyond accredited Baptist ministry, often calling leaders shaped in complementarian contexts. The worry for me is that this may gradually reshape our common life and theology. We face real questions about identity, accountability, and what we expect of those who serve among us. Will we need to begin to create a set of expectations and guidelines that is firmer on how churches and ministers might covenant with and respect those who hold a different view of women in ministry? Will we need to move towards being affirming (or at least accepting) of women in ministry being a requirement rather than a choice?

The Bigger Picture

Overlaying this is the so-called “Quiet Revival.” I love what we are hearing about the number of younger people arriving in our churches and how they are coming to faith and growing in Christ - particularly evident in the rise of numbers of young men. While any movement towards faith is good news, there are uneasy intersections with wider cultural currents, including forms of Christian nationalism and hyper-masculine Christianity. If some young men arrive formed by those narratives, how will that shape our churches? And what will it mean for women’s leadership?

There is anecdotal evidence to suggest that young men are more likely to vote reform and turn up at church and young women are more likely to vote Green and leave. We need to be aware of this and its effect on our churches. In her book “The Struggle to Stay”, author Katie Gaddini writes about how single evangelical women are leaving the church because they are not being enabled to be all they are called to be – because as men step up, they are being sidelined, seemingly only there to fill a gap, rather than be valued as who they are. 

This is echoed in one of the recent comments I have heard from a Baptist minister about women in ministry, stating that we are only there because men are not stepping up.

What happens when these young men step up? Will women be expected to step down by those who hold these views, however quiet and under the radar those views are? 

We need to hold these questions that hang in the air, and be mindful as we disciple those who arrive at our doors, that they are taught to embrace Jesus who loves them just as they are, but not to the detriment of others. 

--------------

I do not pretend to have clear solutions, but I believe we must name what is happening. I ask for others - my brothers in ministry in particular, to pay attention, to listen carefully, and to walk with us towards a more level place—where women are not merely tolerated, but truly able to thrive in God’s call.

Because, in this moment, many of us are exhausted with it all.